web analytics
  • Home
  • Mission
  • Federalist Papers
  • Foundation
  • U.S. Constitution
  • Bill of Rights

The Federalist Press | Reliable Online Political News Service

Breaking News and Political Commentary

  • All Stories
  • Economy
  • Elections
  • Entitlement
  • Ethics
  • Foreign
  • Gender
  • Religion
  • Sci-Tech

What the Trump Presidency Means for the Constitution

November 11, 2016 By Editor 2 Comments

us-constitutionFollowing one of the biggest upsets in modern political history, The Heritage Foundation convened a panel of experts Thursday to examine what a Donald Trump presidency will mean for the Constitution and conservatism as a whole.

“I frankly think that what just happened in this election may have preserved our constitutional republic,” Heritage Foundation President Jim DeMint said in his opening remarks.

DeMint continued:

We know the intent of [Mrs.] Clinton, and she talked a lot about it and what her belief was of the Constitution. And we know Donald Trump has talked about the importance of the Constitution and the list of Supreme Court justices that he released gave us at least some positive indication … to carry out the original intent of the Constitution.

While the Supreme Court is one of the most important issues for voters, according to an exit poll conducted by ABC News, one panelist pointed out that the court is not the only defender of the Constitution.

“It infuriates me how we have come to the point of where we think the Supreme Court is the only guardian of the Constitution,” said Jonah Goldberg, a senior editor at National Review and fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.

Goldberg explained that politicians as well as citizens must also defend the Constitution.

“[The Supreme Court] is a guardian of the Constitution, and in certain formalistic situations, it is the last guardian of the Constitution. But anyone who swears an oath to uphold the Constitution is a guardian of the Constitution, and, the citizens from whom the Constitution derives its authority are guardians of the Constitution,” Goldberg said.

Instead of relying on the Supreme Court, Goldberg believes that Americans should see themselves as the first line of defense when it comes to preserving constitutional principles.

“[W]e’ve gotten to this place where we just basically say, ‘Anything goes unless the Supreme Court, like a hockey goalie, stops it,’” Goldberg said. “And, that is something that the conservative movement … could do a much better job at in terms of creating that incentive structure for politicians.”

trump_russiaTrump’s opportunity to appoint Supreme Court justices who uphold the Constitution will be a top priority of the new administration.

Byron York, chief political correspondent at the Washington Examiner, is hopeful that conservatives will not have to worry about Trump’s choice of justices. He noted that Trump is sensitive to the reactions of his supporters.

“I think the roots of his approach to [the Supreme Court] go back to the early days of the Republican primary when he is trying to consolidate the support of conservatives,” York said. “And he’s got Ted Cruz, whose argued a bunch of cases before the Supreme Court, he’s got governors, he’s got a lot of people who have experience in government and law running against him, and Trump is extremely sensitive to the reactions of audiences.”

York believes that Trump’s perceptiveness of public opinion will be helpful in keeping him true to his word when it comes to filling Supreme Court seats.

“He loves the rallies. He really notices, ‘Do they go for this?,’ ‘Do they not go for this?,’ ‘Did they sit on their hands when I talked about this?,’ and ‘They went crazy when I talked about this!’”

byron_yorkYork said that Trump picked up on the interest Republicans had in the primary about the future of the Supreme Court. The way he consolidated support, according to York, was to publicly release a list of judges that he said he would appoint.

In May, Trump announced that list, then in September, he released a more extensive list. During the final presidential debate in October, Trump said he would “be appointing pro-life judges.”

Confirming those judicial nominees might pose challenges, however. Even with a Republican president and a Republican-controlled Senate, Democrats could still mount a fight against Trump’s nominees using procedural tactics such as the filibuster.

Michael Mukasey, a former U.S. attorney general under President George W. Bush, is confident that this will not be the case.

“Although it is certainly not unprecedented for a nominee not to be voted on when there is a change in an administration, it is unusual to the point of being unprecedented for them to try to block any confirmation,” Mukasey said. “That is a political loser from their standpoint.”

While the Supreme Court is one of the most important issues facing the Trump administration, John Yoo, professor at the UC Berkeley School of Law and fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, said it’s not the only issue.

“It’s not just Supreme Court justices that are important,” Yoo said. “It is also who the attorney general is [and] how the Trump administration is going to interpret and enforce federal law.”

Yoo said that would “have much more of an immediate importance about the Constitution than who he appoints to the Supreme Court.”

Even though Republicans won big on Election Day, Goldberg urged conservatives to remain vigilant and hold leaders accountable.

“Once the honeymoon is over, conservatives need to be set up in a situation where [Trump] has to deal with us and get our approval on the important things,” Goldberg said.

by Rachel del Guidice

@LRacheldG Rachel del Guidice is a member of the Young Leaders Program at The Heritage Foundation. She is a graduate of Franciscan University of Steubenville and the Forge Leadership Network.

Filed Under: All Stories, Economy, Elections, Entitlement, Ethics, Foreign, Gender, Religion, Sci-Tech, Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Timothy G Mooring says

    December 13, 2016 at 12:20 pm

    It’s revealing that you cite John Yoo, best known as an advocate for torture. I do agree that Brown Shirt rallies wiil have play an important role in a a DJT administration.

    Heil Trump

    Reply
  2. Bob Kessener says

    November 11, 2016 at 1:40 pm

    I thoroughly agree, and am encouraged to see this important topic: all citizens and especially those who must take an oath (ref Art 2, Sect 1, last paragraph, and Art 6, last paragraph) to support and defend the US Constitution. 30 years ago, I was shocked when Armen Condo was threatened with contempt of court should he continue to mention the Constitution during his trial. That brave man stood for what it said and was shut down by officials sworn to defend the Constitution.

    Thank you, Jonah Goldberg!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Brit Axton Mysteries Series

Brit Axton Mysteries Series

Brit Axton Mysteries is a series of young adult mystery novels that lead young Brit Axton and her friends on whirlwind adventures to uncover hidden secrets and forgotten treasures.

Byrna Non-lethal Self Protection

Byrna Non-lethal Self Protection

Byrna offers non-lethal self protection at an affordable price. Watch the short video, or click to learn more!

Understanding Cryptocurrency: Essentials for Building Wealth in Digital Currency

Understanding Cryptocurrency: Essentials for Building Wealth in Digital Currency

Understanding Cryptocurrency serves as a definitive guide for novice investors looking to understand the world of cryptocurrency and harness its potential for financial growth and prosperity.

Real Estate Wealth Strategies During High Inflation

Real Estate Wealth Strategies During High Inflation

Real Estate Wealth Strategies During High Inflation is a comprehensive guide on navigating the real estate market, offering strategies and insights for successful investing, during high inflation and interest rates.

Follow us

  • parler
  • welcome-widgets-menus
  • facebook
  • envato

Older Stories

JONATHAN TURLEY: Biden DOJ behind even the Times in pursuing alleged Hunter corruption

‘Buy Low, Sell High’: Market Volatility Creates a Golden Opportunity for Long-Term Investors

“As Seen on TV”: The Commercials Walking a Fine Line Between Hype and Consumer Fraud

Seniors Beware: Misleading Ads Promise Free Money That Doesn’t Exist

New JFK Assassination Files Deepen Questions, Add Fuel to Decades-Old Conspiracy Theories

The Human Cost of the Southern Border Crisis: Trafficking, Exploitation, and the U.S. Demand

Kash Patel Confirmed by Senate and Sworn in as New FBI Director

Older Stories| 2

RFK Jr. Confirmed as HHS Secretary in Historic Senate Vote

DHS ‘Claws Back’ $80 Million from NYC Misdirected for Luxury Migrant Hotels

Tulsi Gabbard Confirmed as Director of National Intelligence

Atty Gen Pam Bondi’s First Actions in Office

Cabinet Pick Scoreboard

Trump and Musk Announce Plans to Shut Down USAID

Mid-Air Collision Near Reagan National Airport Leaves Multiple Fatalities

Older Stories | 3

History and Interpretation of Birthright Citizenship in the United States

White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt Addresses Key Issues in Debut Press Conference

Trump Will Reinstate Troops Forced Out Over COVID Vaccine

Colombia Reverses Course on Accepting Illegal Immigrants Back After Trump Sanctions

Ax Falls on DEI and Saves $420 Million

Pete Hegseth Confirmed as Secretary of Defense: A New Era for U.S. Military Leadership

Trump Brings Relief to Hurricane and Fire Victims

Older Stories | 4

President Trump Signs Executive Order Releasing All Files on JFK, MLK, and RFK Assassinations

Trump Revokes Security Clearances of 51 Ex-Intelligence Officials Who Signed Hunter Biden Laptop Declaration

Jury finds CNN Committed Defamation against Navy Veteran

DAY 1: President Trump Signs Scores of Executive Orders

Trump Proclaims ‘The Golden Age of America Begins Right Now’

Trump Saves TikTok Day Before He’s Sworn In

UAP Recovery Video Shows ‘egg-shaped’ Object

Older Stories | 5

Meta Fact-checkers May Close Doors

Marco Rubio Appears Before Senate Committee for Secretary of State Confirmation

Pam Bondi Appears Before Senate Committee for Attorney General Confirmation

Peace Accord Reached Between Israel and Hamas

Pete Hegseth Appears before Senate

This Easter

Abortion in the 2024 Elections

Recent Comments

  • Ticket- TRANSFER 1.358438 BTC. Confirm > https://graph.org/Ticket--58146-05-02?hs=f529bc2fd635cf32ec23e771eb3b7e2b& on History and Interpretation of Birthright Citizenship in the United States
  • binance kodu on Fed Appeals Court Orders Flynn Case Dismissal
  • + 1.245214 BTC.NEXT - https://graph.org/Ticket--58146-05-02?hs=d5ce88f00ae3f4affbff8ea8792beabb& on Reviving the American Family: Could Financial Incentives Strengthen the Nation’s Social Fabric?
  • Ticket: SENDING 1,598897 BTC. Get => https://graph.org/Ticket--58146-05-02?hs=a33fc6401ac99fa7a880646bef22cf65& on President Trump Signs Executive Order Releasing All Files on JFK, MLK, and RFK Assassinations
  • T059736 on Trump and Musk Announce Plans to Shut Down USAID
  • You have received a email № 266. Read > https://telegra.ph/Message--2868-12-25?hs=58953b0b36cdfe4333bb24a1dcf5f77e& on Elon Musk Purchases Twitter
  • You have received 1 message(-s) № 855. Go > https://telegra.ph/Message--2868-12-25?hs=cb3a3757cd565141d60b747b2d67f487& on Congress Hails DOJ Antitrust Lawsuit vs Google
  • Reminder: Operation 1.8268 BTC. Get > https://telegra.ph/Go-to-your-personal-cabinet-08-25?hs=960ee11ff3fb09accab2cd3799365c3f& on 2-2-22

Copyright © 2025 by Federalist Press · All rights reserved · Website design by RoadRunner CRM · Content Wiriting by GhostWriter · Log in